Menu of Milkhouse Ice Cream in St Johnsbury, Vermont, USA

Menu Overview

Nestled in the heart of St. Johnsbury, Vermont, Milkhouse Ice Cream stands out as a charming destination for both locals and travelers craving authentic New England flavors. Located conveniently at 292 Portland St, just beside a gas station with ample parking, this ice cream shop offers a warm, inviting atmosphere that complements its delicious menu.

The true highlight of Milkhouse’s menu is undoubtedly their Medium Maple Soft Serve Cone topped with chocolate sprinkles. This treat captures the essence of Vermont: rich, creamy maple syrup flavor—perfectly balanced with a dusting of chocolate that adds a subtle crunch and depth. The soft serve, affectionately known as “creemee” in Vermont, is smooth and light, making it a refreshing yet indulgent experience. It’s a perfect example of how simple ingredients can create complex flavors when crafted with care.

Beyond the iconic soft serve, Milkhouse Ice Cream boasts an impressive array of hard ice cream flavors, serving up everything from classic vanilla to inventive, seasonal varieties that celebrate Vermont’s agricultural heritage. One standout menu item mentioned by patrons is the sundae featuring apple cider donut holes topped with maple creemee—truly the highest form of Vermont-style ice cream dessert. This combination melds crisp, spiced apple cider donuts with the velvety sweetness of maple soft serve, delivering a unique texture and a deeply satisfying taste that feels both rustic and refined.

Customer reviews frequently praise the reasonable pricing and generous portions, which make indulging here a guilt-free pleasure. The ambiance reinforces the appeal, with plenty of comfortable seating that invites visitors to linger and savor their sweets. Service is attentive and friendly, creating a welcoming vibe that adds to the overall quality of the experience.

In summary, Milkhouse Ice Cream offers more than just dessert—it offers a connection to Vermont’s rich food culture through thoughtful, well-executed ice cream creations. Whether you’re a fan of traditional creemees or crave an adventurous sundae, this shop promises to satisfy your cravings with genuine flavors and down-to-earth hospitality. It’s a must-stop for anyone exploring St. Johnsbury or the wider Vermont area.